mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant
Back to paper
Download · Edit · History · Raw
/data/papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/REPORT.md
Rendered Markdown.

Extraction report: mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant

Summary

  • Pipeline outputs used (preferred sources):
  • Paper metadata (title/DOI/date/abstract): papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/out/tei.xml
  • Study design + scale + reported tests: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/out/fulltext.md
  • Extraction index/status: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/out/bundle.json
  • Extracted tables:
  • papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/out/tables/ contained no retained numeric tables (table candidates were filtered out by the pipeline heuristics), so it was not used for numeric extraction.
  • Output YAML: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant.yaml
  • Effect sizes:
  • s1_e1, s1_e2, s2_e1 computed from raw-data group summaries in papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using established packages:
    • between-groups: esc::esc_mean_sd
    • within-subject: metafor::escalc(measure="SMCRP") with r_within estimated from data.

Manual interventions / non-pipeline sources (required disclosure)

  • External dataset used (provided in project drive):
  • Source directory: /home/bartosz/Insync/b.mackiewicz@uw.edu.pl/Google Drive/Meta-analizy w filozofii eksperymentalnej/Metaanaliza - stakes, context-sensitivity/Epistemology: Anti-intellectualism and contextualism/DANE_DO_OPRACOWANIA/may
  • Copied into paper directory:
    • papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/data/May et al. KPI Data - Between-Subjects (Exp 1).xls
    • papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/data/May et al. KPI Data - Within-Subjects (Exp 2).xls
  • Used to compute: split Ns, means, SDs, within-person correlation (Study 2), and all d/v.
  • No direct PDF or rendered page-image consultation was needed for extraction (fulltext + TEI + data files were sufficient).

Notes / potential limitations

  • Study 2 contrast (LS-NA vs HS-A) changes both stakes and whether an alternative is mentioned (only HS-A mentions an alternative). This is documented in the effect’s contrast.other_notes.
  • For Study 2 reported tests, p-values are reported as thresholds (p<.001); reported_test.p is set to null with the threshold preserved in reported_test.notes.

Validation / rendering

  • YAML schema validation: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant.yaml validates against docs/stakes_meta_schema.json (via jsonschema).
  • Quarto computation record: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/analysis/effect_sizes.html rendered from papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/analysis/effect_sizes.qmd.
  • HTML extraction report: papers/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant/mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant.html generated via invoke render-extraction mayetal2010practicalinterestsrelevant.

Package recompute check

  • Relative to the previous hand-written formulas:
  • d values did not change for any effect.
  • v changed slightly for between-subject effects only:
    • s1_e1: 0.033159390561 -&gt; 0.033157749548 (delta -0.000001641013)
    • s1_e2: 0.033938271605 -&gt; 0.033928189300 (delta -0.000010082305)
  • s2_e1 (within-subject) is unchanged (d=0.388549287526, v=0.002733530591).