| paper_id | koncewicz2019ocenasilyswiadectw |
|---|---|
| short_label | Koncewicz 2019 |
| citation | Koncewicz, N. (2019). Wpływ kontekstu na ocenę siły świadectw: antyintelektualizm a intuicje potoczne. BA thesis, University of Warsaw. |
| doi | — |
| year | 2019 |
| published | No |
| publication_language | other |
| publication_language_other | Polish |
| research_objective | Test whether practical stakes affect judgments about how confident an agent should be on the basis of different sources of evidence. |
| data_available_online | No |
| data_url | — |
| notes | The thesis reports 753 participants and no exclusions; effect-level Ns are computed from the copied scenario-level raw files. |
| study_id | 1 |
|---|---|
| label | Evidence strength judgments under high and low stakes |
| objective | Compare ratings of how confident Kasia should be in directions to a university under high versus low stakes, across five evidence sources and both single-scenario and two-scenario presentations. |
| study_language | other |
| study_language_other | Polish |
| design | — |
| design_other | Mixed: single-scenario high-vs-low contrasts are between-subjects; two-scenario high-vs-low contrasts are within-subjects. |
| manipulated_factors | Stakes: high versus low; Evidence source: passerby, drunk passerby, police officer, child, road sign; Presentation: single scenario versus high/low scenarios presented together |
| paradigm | Rating confidence in the belief |
| paradigm_other | — |
| notes | Effects s1_e1-s1_e5 are single-scenario between-subject contrasts; effects s1_e6-s1_e10 are two-scenario paired contrasts. |
| n_final | 753 |
|---|---|
| recruitment | volunteers recruited via social media |
| recruitment_other | — |
| compensation | — |
| compensation_other | — |
| characteristics | Online volunteer sample; thesis reports ages 18-75, mean age 25, and no control-question exclusions. |
| mean_age | 25 |
| page | 49 |
|---|---|
| table_ref | — |
| tei_id | — |
| label | Likert 7-point |
|---|---|
| points | 7 |
| anchors | 1 = zupełnie się nie zgadzam; 7 = całkowicie się zgadzam |
| direction | Higher values indicate that Kasia should be more confident. |
| page | 48 |
|---|---|
| table_ref | — |
| tei_id | — |
| knowledge_question_text | — |
|---|---|
| knowledge_question_first | — |
| additional_question_text | Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna tego, że aby dojść na uniwersytet, rzeczywiście trzeba pójść tak, jak [source]? |
other · Navigation to university campus using directions from an evidence source| scenario_code | other |
|---|---|
| scenario_type | Navigation to university campus using directions from an evidence source |
| page | 46 |
|---|---|
| table_ref | — |
| tei_id | — |
s1_e1 · Przechodzień: single scenario · Between-Subjects · d=0.19526226092 · v=0.037590752602| effect_id | s1_e1 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Przechodzień: single scenario |
| subgroup_desc | Passerby source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation |
| design | Between-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.19526226092 |
| v | 0.037590752602 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Medium |
| group_high | przechodzien_single_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | przechodzien_single_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Single-scenario condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta przechodnia, jak dojść na uniwersytet | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce an explicit doubt or counterconsideration. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę... | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Medium | A sober passerby is an ordinary informant without special authority; coded Medium. | Provenance
pyta przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
przechodzien_single_low | Przechodzień / nieważne / single | 52 | 5.0 | 1.37198868114 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
przechodzien_single_high | Przechodzień / ważne / single | 55 | 4.74545454545 | 1.23555628225 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | — |
|---|---|
| t | — |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | — |
| df2 | — |
| p | — |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | — |
s1_e2 · Znaki: single scenario · Between-Subjects · d=0.0822592946169 · v=0.0371192389006| effect_id | s1_e2 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Znaki: single scenario |
| subgroup_desc | Road-sign source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation |
| design | Between-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.0822592946169 |
| v | 0.0371192389006 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | High |
| group_high | znaki_single_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | znaki_single_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Single-scenario condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
na którym znajduje się drogowskaz | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is an external written sign. | Provenance
drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | High | A road sign is an official/artefactual source; coded High. | Provenance
drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
znaki_single_low | Znaki / nieważne / single | 52 | 4.67307692308 | 1.96759187788 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
znaki_single_high | Znaki / ważne / single | 56 | 4.51785714286 | 1.80897832972 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | — |
|---|---|
| t | — |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | — |
| df2 | — |
| p | — |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | — |
s1_e3 · Policjant: single scenario · Between-Subjects · d=0.32692808758 · v=0.0382400093134| effect_id | s1_e3 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Policjant: single scenario |
| subgroup_desc | Police-officer source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation |
| design | Between-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.32692808758 |
| v | 0.0382400093134 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | High |
| group_high | policjant_single_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | policjant_single_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Single-scenario condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta policjanta, jak dojść na uniwersytet | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | High | A police officer is an authoritative informant in the vignette context; coded High. | Provenance
pyta policjanta... Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
policjant_single_low | Policjant / nieważne / single | 53 | 5.30188679245 | 1.2023199635 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
policjant_single_high | Policjant / ważne / single | 53 | 4.8679245283 | 1.44165684396 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | — |
|---|---|
| t | — |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | — |
| df2 | — |
| p | — |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | — |
s1_e4 · Dziecko: single scenario · Between-Subjects · d=0.215371830085 · v=0.036024153076| effect_id | s1_e4 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Dziecko: single scenario |
| subgroup_desc | Child source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation |
| design | Between-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.215371830085 |
| v | 0.036024153076 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Low |
| group_high | dziecko_single_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | dziecko_single_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Single-scenario condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Chłopiec tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Low | The source is explicitly a young child; coded Low. | Provenance
chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dziecko_single_low | Dziecko / nieważne / single | 59 | 4.15254237288 | 1.36221876974 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
dziecko_single_high | Dziecko / ważne / single | 53 | 3.84905660377 | 1.45966574697 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | — |
|---|---|
| t | — |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | — |
| df2 | — |
| p | — |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | — |
s1_e5 · Pijany: single scenario · Between-Subjects · d=0.2695470536 · v=0.0373734056209| effect_id | s1_e5 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Pijany: single scenario |
| subgroup_desc | Drunk-passerby source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation |
| design | Between-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.2695470536 |
| v | 0.0373734056209 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Low |
| group_high | pijany_single_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | pijany_single_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Single-scenario condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta pijanego przechodnia | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
pyta pijanego przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Low | The informant is explicitly drunk; coded Low. | Provenance
pijanego przechodnia |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
pijany_single_low | Pijany / nieważne / single | 54 | 4.01851851852 | 1.53562402952 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
pijany_single_high | Pijany / ważne / single | 54 | 3.57407407407 | 1.75479775593 | — | Provenance
Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | — |
|---|---|
| t | — |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | — |
| df2 | — |
| p | — |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | — |
s1_e6 · Przechodzień: paired scenarios · Within-Subjects · d=0.100228558985 · v=0.0195597015098| effect_id | s1_e6 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Przechodzień: paired scenarios |
| subgroup_desc | Passerby source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation |
| design | Within-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.100228558985 |
| v | 0.0195597015098 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Medium |
| group_high | przechodzien_paired_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | przechodzien_paired_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Two-scenario/paired condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta przechodnia, jak dojść na uniwersytet | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce an explicit doubt or counterconsideration. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę... | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Medium | A sober passerby is an ordinary informant without special authority; coded Medium. | Provenance
pyta przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
przechodzien_paired_low | Przechodzień / nieważne / paired | 51 | 4.23529411765 | 1.64424128757 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
przechodzien_paired_high | Przechodzień / ważne / paired | 51 | 4.05882352941 | 1.8698851805 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | t |
|---|---|
| t | -0.714826225687 |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | 50 |
| df2 | — |
| p | 0.47804087151962 |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.502800788988 used in SMCRP variance. |
| page | — |
|---|---|
| table_ref | analysis/effect_sizes.qmd |
| tei_id | — |
s1_e7 · Znaki: paired scenarios · Within-Subjects · d=0.291740827452 · v=0.0193178887107| effect_id | s1_e7 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Znaki: paired scenarios |
| subgroup_desc | Road-sign source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation |
| design | Within-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.291740827452 |
| v | 0.0193178887107 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | High |
| group_high | znaki_paired_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | znaki_paired_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Two-scenario/paired condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
na którym znajduje się drogowskaz | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is an external written sign. | Provenance
drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | High | A road sign is an official/artefactual source; coded High. | Provenance
drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
znaki_paired_low | Znaki / nieważne / paired | 54 | 4.96296296296 | 1.52912557283 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
znaki_paired_high | Znaki / ważne / paired | 54 | 4.46296296296 | 1.88051541472 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | t |
|---|---|
| t | -2.104837418252 |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | 53 |
| df2 | — |
| p | 0.04006326729097 |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.491627536207 used in SMCRP variance. |
| page | — |
|---|---|
| table_ref | analysis/effect_sizes.qmd |
| tei_id | — |
s1_e8 · Policjant: paired scenarios · Within-Subjects · d=0.395947750285 · v=0.018177554672| effect_id | s1_e8 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Policjant: paired scenarios |
| subgroup_desc | Police-officer source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation |
| design | Within-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.395947750285 |
| v | 0.018177554672 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | High |
| group_high | policjant_paired_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | policjant_paired_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Two-scenario/paired condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta policjanta, jak dojść na uniwersytet | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | High | A police officer is an authoritative informant in the vignette context; coded High. | Provenance
pyta policjanta... Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
policjant_paired_low | Policjant / nieważne / paired | 52 | 5.26923076923 | 1.5096472074 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
policjant_paired_high | Policjant / ważne / paired | 52 | 4.59615384615 | 1.87092946791 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | t |
|---|---|
| t | -2.978340095753 |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | 51 |
| df2 | — |
| p | 0.00442758052431 |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.552972700733 used in SMCRP variance. |
| page | — |
|---|---|
| table_ref | analysis/effect_sizes.qmd |
| tei_id | — |
s1_e9 · Dziecko: paired scenarios · Within-Subjects · d=0.264435395032 · v=0.0201907690571| effect_id | s1_e9 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Dziecko: paired scenarios |
| subgroup_desc | Child source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation |
| design | Within-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | — |
| notes | — |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.264435395032 |
| v | 0.0201907690571 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Low |
| group_high | dziecko_paired_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | dziecko_paired_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Two-scenario/paired condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
Chłopiec tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Low | The source is explicitly a young child; coded Low. | Provenance
chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
dziecko_paired_low | Dziecko / nieważne / paired | 51 | 4.35294117647 | 1.33900753414 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
dziecko_paired_high | Dziecko / ważne / paired | 51 | 3.94117647059 | 1.74827646219 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | t |
|---|---|
| t | -1.849807479036 |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | 50 |
| df2 | — |
| p | 0.07025573857674 |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.496026747497 used in SMCRP variance. |
| page | — |
|---|---|
| table_ref | analysis/effect_sizes.qmd |
| tei_id | — |
s1_e10 · Pijany: paired scenarios · Within-Subjects · d=0.120337417818 · v=0.0324979108369| effect_id | s1_e10 |
|---|---|
| subgroup | Pijany: paired scenarios |
| subgroup_desc | Drunk-passerby source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation |
| design | Within-Subjects |
| design_other | — |
| quality_flags | source_column_name_error_documented |
| notes | The raw paired drunk-passerby file uses PrzechodzenOba column names; the original Rmd explicitly states this is the intended file despite the naming mistake. |
| metric | SMD |
|---|---|
| d | 0.120337417818 |
| v | 0.0324979108369 |
| computed_from | groups |
| needs_review | false |
| notes | Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data. |
| scenario | other |
|---|---|
| skeptical_pressure | No |
| awareness | Yes |
| evidence | External |
| attribution_person | Other |
| evidence_reliability | Low |
| group_high | pijany_paired_high |
|---|---|
| group_low | pijany_paired_low |
| sign_convention | d = mean(low) - mean(high) |
| other_notes | Two-scenario/paired condition. |
| moderator | value | reason | evidence | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
scenario | other | The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary. | Provenance
pyta pijanego przechodnia | ||||||
skeptical_pressure | No | The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt. | Provenance
Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi. | ||||||
awareness | Yes | In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam. | Provenance
Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu. | ||||||
evidence | External | The epistemic basis is testimony from another person. | Provenance
pyta pijanego przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę | ||||||
attribution_person | Other | Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia. | Provenance
Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna... | ||||||
evidence_reliability | Low | The informant is explicitly drunk; coded Low. | Provenance
pijanego przechodnia |
| group_id | label | n | mean | sd | se | provenance | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
pijany_paired_low | Pijany / nieważne / paired | 55 | 4.72727272727 | 1.39382959603 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. | ||||||
pijany_paired_high | Pijany / ważne / paired | 55 | 4.54545454545 | 1.61953561952 | — | Provenance
Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow. |
| test | t |
|---|---|
| t | -0.667766777426 |
| f | — |
| chi2 | — |
| z | — |
| df1 | 54 |
| df2 | — |
| p | 0.50712650351627 |
| reported_d | — |
| reported_r | — |
| notes | Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.108138756473 used in SMCRP variance. Source Rmd notes that the paired drunk-passerby file uses PrzechodzenOba column names by mistake. |
| page | — |
|---|---|
| table_ref | analysis/effect_sizes.qmd |
| tei_id | — |
schema_version: "1.2"
extraction_run:
created_at: "2026-05-06T00:00:00+02:00"
created_by: "Codex"
source_files:
- "pdf/paper.pdf"
- "data/raport_natka.rmd"
- "data/*.csv"
- "data/demo/625672.csv"
- "data/end/255249.csv"
notes: "Thesis used for materials/procedure; raw survey files and report Rmd used as numeric source of truth."
paper:
paper_id: koncewicz2019ocenasilyswiadectw
citation: "Koncewicz, N. (2019). Wpływ kontekstu na ocenę siły świadectw: antyintelektualizm a intuicje potoczne. BA thesis, University of Warsaw."
short_label: "Koncewicz 2019"
doi: null
published: "No"
year: 2019
language: other
language_other: Polish
research_objective: "Test whether practical stakes affect judgments about how confident an agent should be on the basis of different sources of evidence."
data_availability:
data_available_online: "No"
url: null
notes: "Unpublished local thesis dataset and report files are copied into this paper directory."
notes: "The thesis reports 753 participants and no exclusions; effect-level Ns are computed from the copied scenario-level raw files."
studies:
- study_id: 1
label: "Evidence strength judgments under high and low stakes"
language: other
language_other: Polish
objective: "Compare ratings of how confident Kasia should be in directions to a university under high versus low stakes, across five evidence sources and both single-scenario and two-scenario presentations."
sample:
n_final: 753
recruitment: volunteers recruited via social media
recruitment_other: null
compensation: null
compensation_other: null
characteristics: "Online volunteer sample; thesis reports ages 18-75, mean age 25, and no control-question exclusions."
provenance:
page: 49
quote: "W badaniu wzięły udział 753 osoby. Nie wprowadziłam żadnych pytań kontrolnych, więc nikt nie został odrzucony."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
mean_age: 25
mean_age_prov:
page: 49
quote: "Badani byli w przedziale wiekowym od 18 lat do 75 lat, średnia wieku wyniosła 25 lat."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
design: null
design_other: "Mixed: single-scenario high-vs-low contrasts are between-subjects; two-scenario high-vs-low contrasts are within-subjects."
manipulated_factors:
- "Stakes: high versus low"
- "Evidence source: passerby, drunk passerby, police officer, child, road sign"
- "Presentation: single scenario versus high/low scenarios presented together"
paradigm: Rating confidence in the belief
paradigm_other: null
scale:
label: Likert 7-point
points: 7
anchors: "1 = zupełnie się nie zgadzam; 7 = całkowicie się zgadzam"
direction: "Higher values indicate that Kasia should be more confident."
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Skala została opisana liczbami, a krańce podpisane... 1 – zupełnie się nie zgadzam, 7 – całkowicie się zgadzam."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
measures:
knowledge_question_text: null
knowledge_question_first: null
additional_question_text: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna tego, że aby dojść na uniwersytet, rzeczywiście trzeba pójść tak, jak [source]?"
scenarios:
- scenario_code: other
scenario_type: "Navigation to university campus using directions from an evidence source"
high_stakes_text: "Kasia must reach the university by noon for a Portuguese certification exam."
low_stakes_text: "Kasia is sightseeing and is not in a hurry."
provenance:
page: 46
quote: "W sytuacji niskiej stawki wybiera się na spacer... w sytuacji wysokiej stawki musi dostać się... aby przystąpić do egzaminu..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
effects:
- effect_id: s1_e1
subgroup: "Przechodzień: single scenario"
subgroup_desc: "Passerby source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation"
design: Between-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: &przechodzien_mods
scenario: other
skeptical_pressure: "No"
awareness: "Yes"
evidence: External
attribution_person: Other
evidence_reliability: Medium
moderators_coding: &przechodzien_coding
scenario:
provenance:
page: 67
quote: "pyta przechodnia, jak dojść na uniwersytet"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary."
skeptical_pressure:
provenance:
page: 67
quote: "Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce an explicit doubt or counterconsideration."
awareness:
provenance:
page: 67
quote: "Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam."
evidence:
provenance:
page: 67
quote: "Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The epistemic basis is testimony from another person."
attribution_person:
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia."
evidence_reliability:
provenance:
page: 67
quote: "pyta przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "A sober passerby is an ordinary informant without special authority; coded Medium."
contrast:
group_high: przechodzien_single_high
group_low: przechodzien_single_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Single-scenario condition."
groups:
- group_id: przechodzien_single_low
label: "Przechodzień / nieważne / single"
n: 52
mean: 5.0
sd: 1.37198868114
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: przechodzien_single_high
label: "Przechodzień / ważne / single"
n: 55
mean: 4.74545454545
sd: 1.23555628225
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.195262260920
v: 0.0375907526020
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e2
subgroup: "Znaki: single scenario"
subgroup_desc: "Road-sign source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation"
design: Between-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: &znaki_mods
scenario: other
skeptical_pressure: "No"
awareness: "Yes"
evidence: External
attribution_person: Other
evidence_reliability: High
moderators_coding: &znaki_coding
scenario:
provenance:
page: 69
quote: "na którym znajduje się drogowskaz"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary."
skeptical_pressure:
provenance:
page: 69
quote: "Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt."
awareness:
provenance:
page: 69
quote: "Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam."
evidence:
provenance:
page: 69
quote: "drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The epistemic basis is an external written sign."
attribution_person:
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia."
evidence_reliability:
provenance:
page: 69
quote: "drogowskaz z informacją o objeździe"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "A road sign is an official/artefactual source; coded High."
contrast:
group_high: znaki_single_high
group_low: znaki_single_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Single-scenario condition."
groups:
- group_id: znaki_single_low
label: "Znaki / nieważne / single"
n: 52
mean: 4.67307692308
sd: 1.96759187788
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: znaki_single_high
label: "Znaki / ważne / single"
n: 56
mean: 4.51785714286
sd: 1.80897832972
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.0822592946169
v: 0.0371192389006
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e3
subgroup: "Policjant: single scenario"
subgroup_desc: "Police-officer source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation"
design: Between-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: &policjant_mods
scenario: other
skeptical_pressure: "No"
awareness: "Yes"
evidence: External
attribution_person: Other
evidence_reliability: High
moderators_coding: &policjant_coding
scenario:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "pyta policjanta, jak dojść na uniwersytet"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary."
skeptical_pressure:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt."
awareness:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam."
evidence:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The epistemic basis is testimony from another person."
attribution_person:
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia."
evidence_reliability:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "pyta policjanta... Policjant tłumaczy jej trasę"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "A police officer is an authoritative informant in the vignette context; coded High."
contrast:
group_high: policjant_single_high
group_low: policjant_single_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Single-scenario condition."
groups:
- group_id: policjant_single_low
label: "Policjant / nieważne / single"
n: 53
mean: 5.30188679245
sd: 1.2023199635
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: policjant_single_high
label: "Policjant / ważne / single"
n: 53
mean: 4.8679245283
sd: 1.44165684396
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.326928087580
v: 0.0382400093134
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e4
subgroup: "Dziecko: single scenario"
subgroup_desc: "Child source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation"
design: Between-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: &dziecko_mods
scenario: other
skeptical_pressure: "No"
awareness: "Yes"
evidence: External
attribution_person: Other
evidence_reliability: Low
moderators_coding: &dziecko_coding
scenario:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "pyta chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary."
skeptical_pressure:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt."
awareness:
provenance:
page: 71
quote: "Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam."
evidence:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "Chłopiec tłumaczy jej trasę"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The epistemic basis is testimony from another person."
attribution_person:
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia."
evidence_reliability:
provenance:
page: 70
quote: "chłopca wyglądającego mniej więcej na 8 lat"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The source is explicitly a young child; coded Low."
contrast:
group_high: dziecko_single_high
group_low: dziecko_single_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Single-scenario condition."
groups:
- group_id: dziecko_single_low
label: "Dziecko / nieważne / single"
n: 59
mean: 4.15254237288
sd: 1.36221876974
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: dziecko_single_high
label: "Dziecko / ważne / single"
n: 53
mean: 3.84905660377
sd: 1.45966574697
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.215371830085
v: 0.0360241530760
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e5
subgroup: "Pijany: single scenario"
subgroup_desc: "Drunk-passerby source; high-low contrast in single-scenario presentation"
design: Between-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: &pijany_mods
scenario: other
skeptical_pressure: "No"
awareness: "Yes"
evidence: External
attribution_person: Other
evidence_reliability: Low
moderators_coding: &pijany_coding
scenario:
provenance:
page: 68
quote: "pyta pijanego przechodnia"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette is a navigation/directions case, outside the fixed scenario vocabulary."
skeptical_pressure:
provenance:
page: 68
quote: "Kasia mogłaby zrobić więcej, aby się upewnić... ale tego nie robi."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The vignette notes possible further checking but does not introduce explicit doubt."
awareness:
provenance:
page: 68
quote: "Musi tam być o 12.00... Ma bardzo mało czasu."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "In the high-stakes variant, the protagonist is explicitly aware of time pressure and the exam."
evidence:
provenance:
page: 68
quote: "pyta pijanego przechodnia... Przechodzień tłumaczy jej trasę"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The epistemic basis is testimony from another person."
attribution_person:
provenance:
page: 48
quote: "Jak myślisz, na ile Kasia powinna być pewna..."
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "Participants evaluate a third-person confidence judgment about Kasia."
evidence_reliability:
provenance:
page: 68
quote: "pijanego przechodnia"
tei_id: null
table_ref: null
reason: "The informant is explicitly drunk; coded Low."
contrast:
group_high: pijany_single_high
group_low: pijany_single_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Single-scenario condition."
groups:
- group_id: pijany_single_low
label: "Pijany / nieważne / single"
n: 54
mean: 4.01851851852
sd: 1.53562402952
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: pijany_single_high
label: "Pijany / ważne / single"
n: 54
mean: 3.57407407407
sd: 1.75479775593
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from scenario-level raw survey files in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.269547053600
v: 0.0373734056209
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed from raw group means/SDs in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd using esc::esc_mean_sd."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e6
subgroup: "Przechodzień: paired scenarios"
subgroup_desc: "Passerby source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation"
design: Within-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: *przechodzien_mods
moderators_coding: *przechodzien_coding
contrast:
group_high: przechodzien_paired_high
group_low: przechodzien_paired_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Two-scenario/paired condition."
groups:
- group_id: przechodzien_paired_low
label: "Przechodzień / nieważne / paired"
n: 51
mean: 4.23529411765
sd: 1.64424128757
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: przechodzien_paired_high
label: "Przechodzień / ważne / paired"
n: 51
mean: 4.05882352941
sd: 1.8698851805
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
reported_test:
test: t
t: -0.714826225687
df1: 50
p: 0.47804087151962
notes: "Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.502800788988 used in SMCRP variance."
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Recomputed from paired raw data in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "analysis/effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.100228558985
v: 0.0195597015098
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e7
subgroup: "Znaki: paired scenarios"
subgroup_desc: "Road-sign source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation"
design: Within-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: *znaki_mods
moderators_coding: *znaki_coding
contrast:
group_high: znaki_paired_high
group_low: znaki_paired_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Two-scenario/paired condition."
groups:
- group_id: znaki_paired_low
label: "Znaki / nieważne / paired"
n: 54
mean: 4.96296296296
sd: 1.52912557283
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: znaki_paired_high
label: "Znaki / ważne / paired"
n: 54
mean: 4.46296296296
sd: 1.88051541472
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
reported_test:
test: t
t: -2.104837418252
df1: 53
p: 0.04006326729097
notes: "Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.491627536207 used in SMCRP variance."
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Recomputed from paired raw data in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "analysis/effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.291740827452
v: 0.0193178887107
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e8
subgroup: "Policjant: paired scenarios"
subgroup_desc: "Police-officer source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation"
design: Within-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: *policjant_mods
moderators_coding: *policjant_coding
contrast:
group_high: policjant_paired_high
group_low: policjant_paired_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Two-scenario/paired condition."
groups:
- group_id: policjant_paired_low
label: "Policjant / nieważne / paired"
n: 52
mean: 5.26923076923
sd: 1.5096472074
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: policjant_paired_high
label: "Policjant / ważne / paired"
n: 52
mean: 4.59615384615
sd: 1.87092946791
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
reported_test:
test: t
t: -2.978340095753
df1: 51
p: 0.00442758052431
notes: "Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.552972700733 used in SMCRP variance."
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Recomputed from paired raw data in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "analysis/effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.395947750285
v: 0.018177554672
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e9
subgroup: "Dziecko: paired scenarios"
subgroup_desc: "Child source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation"
design: Within-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: *dziecko_mods
moderators_coding: *dziecko_coding
contrast:
group_high: dziecko_paired_high
group_low: dziecko_paired_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Two-scenario/paired condition."
groups:
- group_id: dziecko_paired_low
label: "Dziecko / nieważne / paired"
n: 51
mean: 4.35294117647
sd: 1.33900753414
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: dziecko_paired_high
label: "Dziecko / ważne / paired"
n: 51
mean: 3.94117647059
sd: 1.74827646219
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
reported_test:
test: t
t: -1.849807479036
df1: 50
p: 0.07025573857674
notes: "Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.496026747497 used in SMCRP variance."
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Recomputed from paired raw data in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "analysis/effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.264435395032
v: 0.0201907690571
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data."
quality_flags: []
notes: null
- effect_id: s1_e10
subgroup: "Pijany: paired scenarios"
subgroup_desc: "Drunk-passerby source; high-low contrast in two-scenario presentation"
design: Within-Subjects
design_other: null
moderators: *pijany_mods
moderators_coding: *pijany_coding
contrast:
group_high: pijany_paired_high
group_low: pijany_paired_low
sign_convention: "d = mean(low) - mean(high)"
other_notes: "Two-scenario/paired condition."
groups:
- group_id: pijany_paired_low
label: "Pijany / nieważne / paired"
n: 55
mean: 4.72727272727
sd: 1.39382959603
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
- group_id: pijany_paired_high
label: "Pijany / ważne / paired"
n: 55
mean: 4.54545454545
sd: 1.61953561952
se: null
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Computed from paired scenario raw survey file in raport_natka.rmd workflow."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "raport_natka.rmd; effect_sizes.qmd"
reported_test:
test: t
t: -0.667766777426
df1: 54
p: 0.50712650351627
notes: "Paired t-test computed as high minus low; within-person r=0.108138756473 used in SMCRP variance. Source Rmd notes that the paired drunk-passerby file uses PrzechodzenOba column names by mistake."
provenance:
page: null
quote: "Recomputed from paired raw data in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd."
tei_id: null
table_ref: "analysis/effect_sizes.qmd"
effect_size:
metric: SMD
d: 0.120337417818
v: 0.0324979108369
computed_from: groups
needs_review: false
notes: "Computed in analysis/effect_sizes.qmd with metafor::escalc(measure='SMCRP', correct=FALSE), using within-person r from raw data."
quality_flags:
- source_column_name_error_documented
notes: "The raw paired drunk-passerby file uses PrzechodzenOba column names; the original Rmd explicitly states this is the intended file despite the naming mistake."
notes: "Effects s1_e1-s1_e5 are single-scenario between-subject contrasts; effects s1_e6-s1_e10 are two-scenario paired contrasts."