grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge
Back to paper
Download · Edit · History · Raw
/data/papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/REPORT.md
Rendered Markdown.

Extraction report: grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge

Summary

  • Pipeline outputs used (preferred sources):
  • Extraction index/status: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/bundle.json
  • Study design + participants + scenario wording: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/fulltext.md and papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/text.txt
  • Numeric results used for primary effect sizes (first-block between-subject emulation):
    • Experiment 1 Table 7: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/tables/camelot_stream_p15_t3.csv
    • Experiment 2 Table 8 When presented first columns: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/tables/camelot_stream_p19_t4.csv
  • Additional supplemental within-subject results now included in the computation notebook:
    • Experiment 1 Table 6: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/tables/camelot_stream_p12_t2.csv
    • Experiment 2 Table 8 Overall columns: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/tables/camelot_stream_p19_t4.csv
    • Paired-samples t tests and omnibus within-subject analyses: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/out/fulltext.md
  • Output YAML: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge.yaml
  • Computations:
  • The YAML now contains both designs for downstream synthesis:
    • the original first-block between-subject estimates, and
    • additional all-response within-subject estimates computed with within_smcrp_t (paired t used to recover within-person r).
  • papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/analysis/effect_sizes.qmd audits both sets of computations.
  • The Quarto audit also verifies that the paper's reported repeated-measures d values are recoverable from t / sqrt(n) up to rounding tolerance, which indicates that the paper is using a different repeated-measures standardization than the project metric.

Manual interventions / non-pipeline sources (required disclosure)

  • External public bibliographic records were consulted to confirm publication metadata:
  • University of Reading CentAUR record for the published article.
  • University of Manchester Research Explorer record (lists DOI 10.1111/mila.12196 and publication date July 5, 2018).
  • The PDF (and rendered page images) were not consulted; all effect-size inputs still come from pipeline outputs.

Notes / potential limitations

  • This paper’s “context” manipulation bundles multiple cues (higher stakes for the ascriber + explicit error-possibility/skeptical-pressure cues). The extracted effects therefore represent the combined context shift, not a pure stakes-only manipulation.
  • The local manuscript-style header in out/fulltext.md still contains the line “Published on February 10, 2010”, which is bibliographically false and was ignored in favor of the public publication records.
  • The extraction now codes both the six first-block between-subject effects and six supplemental all-response within-subject effects in the YAML.
  • The computation notebook audits both sets of effects, with the within-subject effects using the project's SMCRP convention.
  • The paper’s own repeated-measures d values are comparable in magnitude to the project estimates, but they are not numerically identical because the paper appears to report d_z = t / sqrt(n) whereas the project uses the pooled-SD repeated-measures metric implemented in docs/quarto_effect_template.qmd.

Human input needed (clearly delimited fields)

  • None at present for publication metadata; DOI and published status were confirmed from public records.

Validation / rendering

  • YAML schema validation: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge.yaml validates against docs/stakes_meta_schema.json (via jsonschema).
  • Effect-size notebook render: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/analysis/effect_sizes.html rendered successfully via quarto render.
  • Extraction HTML render: papers/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge/grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge.html rendered successfully via conda run -n meta-extract meta-extract render-extraction grindrodetalndthirdpersonknowledge.